Case Update: Our Opposition to Apple’s Motion to Dismiss the Santa Clara Semiconductor Fab Case10/9/2026 Gjøvik v. Apple Inc., No. 5:25-cv-07360-PCP (N.D. Cal.)On October 8, 2026, I filed my opposition to Apple’s motion to dismiss my environmental lawsuit about the semiconductor fabrication facility Apple operates at 3250 Scott Boulevard in Santa Clara. The court will hear the motion on November 5, 2026. This update explains what the case is about, where it stands, and what the public record shows.
Apple operates a chip fabrication facility, commonly called a “fab,” in a building it leases at 3250 Scott Boulevard. Semiconductor fabrication uses highly toxic and flammable gases and generates hazardous waste. This facility sits across the street from the Santa Clara Square Apartments, more than 1,800 homes, along with a public park and a children’s playground. A creek trail runs alongside it. I lived in those apartments in 2020 and became seriously ill there. I later learned what was operating across the street. Since then I have filed complaints with environmental agencies, and some of those complaints led to inspections and enforcement. In September 2025, I filed this lawsuit. The lawsuit is a “citizen suit.” Federal environmental laws, including the Clean Air Act, the Clean Water Act, the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (which governs hazardous waste), the Emergency Planning and Community Right-to-Know Act, and the Toxic Substances Control Act, allow members of the public to go to court to enforce them. A citizen must first give the company and the government notice and an opportunity to act. If the violations continue, the citizen may sue. The relief is aimed at compliance: court orders requiring the facility to follow the law, and civil penalties paid to the U.S. Treasury. The case also includes a public nuisance claim under California law against Apple and the property owners. The current complaint is the Third Amended Complaint (Dkt. 119). In September, Apple and the property owners moved to dismiss it (Dkt. 128; Dkt. 130). A motion to dismiss does not ask the court to decide what happened. It asks whether the case can go forward at all, assuming the facts in the complaint are true. At this stage, the court accepts the complaint’s factual allegations and asks whether they state a legal claim. The question is not who wins, but whether the case continues to the stage where evidence is exchanged. My opposition (Dkt. 133) is supported by a declaration with photographs, water testing records, and agency correspondence (Dkt. 135). It also includes a request asking the court to consider public records and filings from other proceedings (Dkt. 134). Much of this case rests on Apple’s own documents and on records from government agencies. A few examples: What the facility is. Apple’s Risk Management Plan for the site reports that the facility stores arsine, chlorine, and anhydrous ammonia above federal threshold quantities. It classifies the facility’s processes under a computer and electronic product manufacturing code, and it identifies about 100 employees working on those processes (Dkt. 134-6). In 2016, the regional wastewater agency reissued Apple’s discharge permit under the federal standards for semiconductor manufacturing (Dkt. 134-7). Apple’s 2023 air permit application describes the facility as a “Semiconductor Fab” (TAC ¶ 161). How far a worst-case release could reach. According to the complaint, Apple’s own hazard modeling places the worst-case toxic endpoint for an arsine release at 1.1 miles from the facility. That area includes more than 5,000 residents, the San Tomas Aquino Creek Trail, light rail, and Highway 101. The complaint also notes that the analysis did not account for the apartments directly across the street (TAC ¶ 188). Use above permit limits. In a sworn 2024 report to the Bay Area Air Quality Management District, Apple reported using arsine, phosphine, and boron trichloride at 84%, 61%, and 824% above the annual caps in its air permit (TAC ¶ 178). Toxic release reporting. Federal law requires covered manufacturing facilities to report their releases of listed toxic chemicals each year to EPA’s Toxics Release Inventory. That database is how communities learn what is being released near them. Apple filed one report for this facility, covering 2020, which disclosed more than 17,000 pounds of the industrial solvent NMP (Dkt. 119-4). That report, like the Risk Management Plan, used a manufacturing industry code that falls within the reporting program, and EPA’s own records list semiconductor manufacturing codes for the site. No report has been filed since. In this case, Apple relies on a research-and-development code from a separate registration, which the reporting program does not cover. A record of violations. In 2025, EPA resolved an enforcement action identifying nineteen categories of hazardous waste violations at the facility. The violations included a 1,700-gallon solvent waste tank that operated without a permit and vented to the atmosphere. The regional air district issued Notices of Violation for operating equipment without required permits. A City inspection in January 2026 found further violations. EPA’s public compliance database lists the facility as out of compliance in nine of the twelve most recent quarters (Dkt. 119-4). The opposition responds to each of the motion’s arguments. Its central points are these. The people who live near a facility can enforce the law. The Supreme Court has long held that a person who uses an area, and whose use and enjoyment of it are diminished by pollution, may bring a citizen suit. I live nearby and regularly use the creek trail and parks beside the facility. I have photographed foam, sheen, and discoloration in the creek downstream of the facility’s stormwater outfall, and I have changed how I use the area because of these conditions. The notice process worked as intended. The notice requirement exists so that agencies can act before anyone goes to court. Here, they did. EPA’s own records reflect that its inspection began with my tip, and the inspection led to an enforcement action. The air district issued Notices of Violation shortly after my complaint to it. Administrative penalties do not end the matter. Congress barred citizen suits only where the government is actively prosecuting a case in court to bring a facility into compliance. The agency settlements here were administrative, and they imposed penalties without requiring compliance. EPA’s settlement expressly preserves the right to seek injunctive relief. The law follows what a facility does, not what it is called. Whether a site is labeled research and development or manufacturing, its legal obligations depend on its actual operations. In my earlier case against Apple, Apple pointed to public permits identifying the site as a “Fab.” When the judge described Apple’s defense as resting on a permit that “made it clear . . . that there was semiconductor fabrication going on,” Apple’s counsel answered, “Correct, Your Honor” (Dkt. 134-4). Positions taken in one court should hold in another. In that same earlier case, Apple told the court that this environmental case was “factually and legally distinct,” and the court declined to treat the cases as related (Dkt. 11-1; Dkt. 12). The opposition explains why Apple cannot now argue that this case is barred as a repeat of that one. Semiconductor manufacturing is expanding across the United States, much of it near homes, schools, and parks. The laws at issue in this case were written for exactly that situation. They require facilities to hold valid permits, to stay within their limits, and to tell the public what they release. They also give the people who live nearby a way to insist on compliance when other safeguards fall short. This case asks whether those protections apply to a fab operating across the street from a residential neighborhood. I believe the law answers that question clearly. Apple may file a reply brief. Judge P. Casey Pitts will then hear argument on November 5, 2026, at 10:00 a.m. in Courtroom 8, 4th Floor, at the Robert F. Peckham Federal Building and U.S. Courthouse, 280 South First Street, San José. Federal court hearings are open to the public. The full docket is available on CourtListener.
Thank you to everyone who has followed this case and offered support along the way. -Ashley
0 Comments
RESIDENTS AND ADVOCATES TO RALLY AT SANTA CLARA CITY HALL OVER APPLE’S SECRET CHIP FAB NEXT TO HOMES, PARKS, AND A CHILDREN’S SCHOOL Press conference precedes City Council meeting; follows amended federal lawsuit seeking to shut down hazardous semiconductor plant at 3250 Scott Blvd, Santa Clara, California. SANTA CLARA, Calif. — Community members, labor advocates, and environmental activists will hold a press conference and rally on Tuesday, August 18, outside Santa Clara City Hall (1500 Warburton Avenue), ahead of that evening’s City Council meeting, to demand the City stop protecting an unmarked, high-hazard semiconductor fabrication plant (“chip fab”) operated by Apple Inc. at 3250 Scott Boulevard — directly across the street from the 1,840-unit Santa Clara Square Apartments, public city parks, children’s playgrounds, a church and Whole Foods, and the San Tomas Aquino/Saratoga Creek. WHO: Ashley Gjovik, former Apple senior engineering program manager, environmental whistleblower, and plaintiff in Gjovik v. Apple Inc., City of Santa Clara, et al.; community members; labor and environmental advocates. WHAT: Press conference and rally regarding the federal environmental citizen suit seeking to shut down hazardous operations at the chip fab — followed by attendance and public comment at the Santa Clara City Council meeting. WHEN: Tuesday, August 18, 2026. Press conference and rally at 6:00 PM; City Council meeting begins at 7:00 PM. Attendees are encouraged to arrive at 6:00 PM and stay through the Council meeting. WHERE: Santa Clara City Hall, 1500 Warburton Avenue, Santa Clara, CA 95050 (rally outside; Council meeting in the Council Chambers). CAN’T ATTEND IN PERSON? The Council meeting is a hybrid meeting — join and speak during public comment via Zoom:
Supporters joining remotely are encouraged to sign on by 7:00 PM and speak during the public comment period. Full participation instructions: santaclaraca.gov > City Clerk’s Office > Watch and Participate in Public Meetings. (https://www.santaclaraca.gov/our-city/departments-a-f/city-clerk-s-office/city-council-meetings/watch-and-participate-in-public-meetings) The Santa Clara City Clerk’s Office confirmed that no pre-registration to speak; in-person speakers fill out a speaker card in the Chambers; Zoom speakers use “Raise Hand”; 3 minutes per speaker; written public comments and any presentation materials (PowerPoint/PDF) go to [email protected] by 12:00 PM (noon) on Tuesday, August 18. Make your voice heard! An optional draft template for written comment is below:
My public comment and public presentation slides.
SPEAK DURING “PUBLIC PRESENTATIONS”: Speakers will address the Council during the “Public Presentations” portion of the meeting which is open to anyone attending in person or via Zoom. Gjovik and other advocates will speak during Public Presentations, and all community members are invited to speak as well including sharing thoughts about fenceline communities, responsible zoning in the City of Santa Clara, and the issues in this lawsuit. Speakers may use their few minutes to share their views, or to formally request that the Council place these issues on a future meeting agenda under Council Policy 030 (“Adding an Item to the Agenda”): https://www.santaclaraca.gov/home/showpublisheddocument/82368/638354905782130000. The entire meeting, including every Public Presentations speaker, is livestreamed and recorded, with playback available on the City’s website (santaclara.legistar.com), Facebook page, and YouTube channel (youtube.com/cityofsantaclara). Every comment becomes part of the public record. WHY: On August 6, 2026, Gjovik filed a Second Amended Complaint in federal court (N.D. Cal. Case No. 5:25-cv-07360-PCP) bringing thirty-five claims against Apple, the City of Santa Clara, and the property owners under the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act, Clean Air Act, Clean Water Act, Emergency Planning and Community Right-to-Know Act, Toxic Substances Control Act, and California public nuisance law. The suit seeks removal of the facility’s hazardous chemicals and toxic gases, community warnings, and enforcement of the environmental laws that federal, state, and local regulators have documented the facility violating for a decade. The facility — which bears no company name and no street-visible hazard warnings — stores and uses acutely lethal gases including arsine, phosphine, and chlorine. Apple’s own worst-case dispersion modeling places its arsine toxic endpoint at 1.1 miles, covering thousands of residents. A school serving up to 900 children sits within that radius; in a chemical emergency, the school’s evacuation plan directs children to assemble at a park directly across the street from the plant. The lawsuit follows government enforcement triggered by Gjovik’s complaints. In October 2025, the U.S. EPA resolved seven federal hazardous waste counts against Apple’s facility through a Consent Agreement and Final Order with a monetary penalty — an action EPA’s own records credit to Gjovik’s tip. In May 2026, the Bay Area Air Quality Management District settled air quality violations at the site, including operating emission sources without required permits. Sworn testimony and records obtained in related litigation — cited throughout the amended complaint — include Apple’s own hazard analysis identifying failure scenarios resulting in “injury and/or fatality” to site personnel or neighbors, and Apple’s admission that it is still using the facility today. The complaint also details the City of Santa Clara’s role: approving thousands of apartments beside the fab while omitting it from the project’s environmental review, failing its state-delegated hazardous materials enforcement duties, and — in 2025 — formally amending its General Plan after City officials stated on the record that the area is “not an appropriate area for housing” and “we do not want housing there.” Decades earlier, in LSI Logic Corp. v. City of Santa Clara, the California Court of Appeal rejected this same City’s attempt to site children next to chip fabs. “I almost died in an apartment across the street from this factory. When I went to agencies asking for help, no one knew or would admit this chip fab even existed. Six years later, the plant is still running, still unmarked, and still next to a children’s playground. The agencies fined Apple and moved on. The City rezoned its mistake and left my neighbors and coworkers behind. Nobody even warned the families who live there — so we’re going to court, and we’re going to City Hall.” - Ashley Gjovik Speakers will address the litigation, the enforcement record, the City’s ongoing refusal to warn residents, and calls for the Council to act. After the 6:00 PM rally, participants will move inside to attend the 7:00 PM Council meeting and speak during public comment — in person and via Zoom. Visuals include signs, the facility’s hazard placard imagery, and maps of the plume radius over the surrounding homes, parks, and school. Case: Gjovik v. Apple Inc., City of Santa Clara, Property Owners (Jenab, Lindsey, et al.), N.D. Cal. No. 5:25-cv-07360-PCP. The Second Amended Complaint and exhibits are available on the public court docket via CourtListener: https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/71272728/gjovik-v-apple-inc/ Media Contact: Ashley Gjovik [email protected] | Steve Zeltzer & Labor Media [email protected] | Friends of Saratoga Creek friendsofsaratogacreek.org | On September 2 2025, I filed an environmental Citizen Suit in the United States District Court for the Northern District of California. The defendants are Apple Inc., the City of Santa Clara, and the property owner. The cases arises out of activities at a modern semiconductor fabrication facility. I'm alleging violations of five federal environmental statutes—the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA), Clean Air Act (CAA), Clean Water Act (CWA), Emergency Planning and Community Right-to-Know Act (EPCRA), and Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA)—and California public nuisance law. On October 10 2025, the City of Santa Clara filed a Motion to Dismiss requesting to remove themselves from the lawsuit, generally claiming immunity from liability due to their status as a municipal government. On October 25, 2025, I filed my Opposition and Request for Judicial Notice. The hearing is scheduled for November 20, 2025 in San Jose federal court.
In Santa Clara County in the 1970s and 1980s, the County (including City of Santa Clara) became ground zero for semiconductor manufacturing disasters. Reckless industrial practices led to toxic waste dumps, groundwater contamination, chemical spills, deaths, evacuations, and toxic clouds. The result: Santa Clara County ended up with the most Superfund cleanup sites in the nation. Congress looked at what happened in Santa Clara County and enacted the federal environmental laws at issue in this case. RCRA, CERCLA, CAA, CWA, and EPCRA exist largely because of what happened here. Local regulations created in response to Santa Clara County disasters—like the Toxic Gas Ordinance and silane-specific safety regulations—were later adopted nationally in the International Fire Code. The semiconductor fabrication facility at 3250 Scott Boulevard uses some of the most dangerous chemicals in industrial manufacturing including arsine, phosphine, mercury, silane, and extensive industrial solvents while sitting extraordinarily close to residential housing. The facility is also adjacent to two city-owned parks: Meadow Park and Creekside Park. Both parks are advertised on the city's website and feature playgrounds, BBQ facilities, and fitness equipment. The city invites the public to use these parks. The city knows these specific chemicals have caused deaths and mass casualties. The city knows the community has fought for decades against locating these facilities near homes. The city cannot claim ignorance or good faith. In 2023 and 2024, the EPA conducted inspections and found RCRA violations at the facility. According to EPA records, the facility reported releasing 16,083 pounds of air pollutants annually and its currently facing multiple air pollution violations from the Bay Area Air Quality Mgmt District. Beginning in at least 2020, multiple residents filed complaints with the city about chemical exposure. The city did nothing. The City of Santa Clara voluntarily became a Certified Unified Program Agency (CUPA). This means the city demanded exclusive control over enforcement of federal hazardous waste laws at the local level. Only three cities in Santa Clara County chose to take on this responsibility. The city positioned itself as the local enforcer of RCRA, CAA, CWA, and EPCRA. According to the city's own 2025 Operating Budget, Santa Clara employs just 3.95 full-time equivalent employees for CUPA administration and enforcement for the entire city. The budget reveals the city's enforcement priorities:
Between 2015 and 2017, the city approved the development of over 2,000 residential units at the Santa Clara Square Apartments location. During this approval process, the city kept the semiconductor facility's operations out of the Environmental Impact Report. The city never disclosed to future residents what was next door. This violated the city's own General Plan, which requires restricting "the use and storage of hazardous materials for industrial uses within 500 feet of existing residential uses." When residents began experiencing chemical exposure, the city concealed information. In 2020 and 2021, I and other residents filed complaints with the city. I spoke directly with the Mayor Lisa Gillmor and Gary Welling, the Water and Sewer Director, about the chemical exposure. Other victims of chemical exposure also contacted both of them. The city did nothing, disclosed nothing, and stopped nothing. Instead, the city concealed ongoing violations rather than reporting them to CalOES or EPA as required. The city refused Public Records Act requests. The city may have even tipped off the facility about an unannounced EPA inspection—which would constitute a federal crime. In response to my Public Records Act request, the city stated it has no documentation of ever enforcing the Toxic Gas Ordinance—an ordinance created specifically to prevent catastrophic disasters at facilities exactly like 3250 Scott Boulevard. The federal environmental statutes at issue expressly authorize citizen suits against government agencies:
The EPA found RCRA violations at the facility in 2023 and 2024. The city was aware of these violations for years and did not even document them, let alone cite them. The city further concealed violations by omitting details from public records and refused Public Records Act requests. The city may have also tipped off the facility about an EPA inspection, which would be a criminal violation of RCRA -- and repeatedly refused to respond to Public Records requests about this despite there certainly being evidence of communications that led to their ad hoc "inspection" the same day as the unannounced EPA inspection. The facility releases over 16,000 pounds of air pollutants annually, including mercury, arsenic, phosphine, benzene, toluene, NMP, silane, and formaldehyde. The city knew there were not required air permits or abatement technology, the city knew the releases would enter the apartments and parks, and they failed to stop it, report it, warn the residents, or refer the matter to the Air Quality Management District. The city contributed to the construction and operation of a major emitting facility without required air permits, and that facility has already caused irreparable harm. The city also holds a municipal NPDES Permit (No. CAS612008) with specific requirements. The permit mandates that the city "shall implement an industrial and commercial site control program" and "shall conduct inspections, effective follow-up, and enforcement to abate potential and actual non-stormwater discharges." The city violated these permit terms. The city failed to implement the required site control program, failed to conduct proper inspections and enforcement, and failed to respond to complaints about pollution. The stormwater at the facility accumulates (at least) the same pollution being released into the air, and then that storm water flows directly the SF Bay and the Pacific Ocean. The city also took on the role of emergency response commission under EPCRA and has direct mandatory obligations to report EPCRA matters to CalOES. The city failed to report known hazardous substance releases. The city concealed information instead of providing it to the community, directly violating the "Right-to-Know" purpose of EPCRA. The city refused to report violations to CalOES or EPA as required. The city helped conceal and enable ongoing violations with releases of extremely dangerous chemicals that could cause mass fatalities. The city also knew about the use, storage, and releases of lead, mercury, TCE, formaldehyde, and NMP at the facility. The city knew these toxic substances were being mishandled, were not being property reported or controlled, and that the reckless handling of these TSCA regulated substances had and was causing injury to the public and environment. The city failed to report TSCA violations to the EPA, while helping to conceal and enable ongoing violations. The city didn't just fail to enforce environmental laws. The city actively participated in the violations, encouraging and enabling those violations, with full knowledge of the risk and harm. The city approved residential development while concealing what the facility was doing next door. The city kept the facility's operations out of the Environmental Impact Report. The city received direct complaints from injured residents and concealed information rather than acting. The city refused to disclose the facility's activities to people who were being harmed. The city financially benefits from enabling violations through tax revenue and other sources. The criminal provisions of RCRA, CAA, and CWA apply to "any person"—not just facility owners and operators. These provisions can reach contractors, accomplices, and anyone who knowingly contributes to violations. The city's conduct—concealment, enabling, and potential obstruction of EPA enforcement—creates plausible criminal liability. If the city has plausible criminal liability under these statutes, it certainly has civil liability under the citizen suit provisions. This is a novel legal theory in environmental citizen suits. Most cases involve cities that passively fail to enforce laws. This case involves a city that actively conspired with violators and aided their violations. I'm arguing that contribution, conspiracy, and similar theories apply when a defendant crosses the line from passive regulator to active participant. Further, under California Government Code § 830, public entities are liable for dangerous conditions on their property when they fail to warn or protect against known dangers. The city owns Meadow Park and Creekside Park. Both parks are located less than 230 feet from the facility. The city advertises these parks on its official website and invites the public to use them. The parks feature playgrounds, BBQ facilities, and fitness equipment. The parks are contaminated by and exposed to toxic releases from the facility (air, soil, groundwater, stormwater, sewer vapor, etc). The city knew about the dangers and failed to warn park users or take protective measures, and instead invited vulnerable populations to come to the parks, assuring them the parks were safe. I personally used both parks and was injured. I experienced dizziness, difficulty breathing, rashes, and gastrointestinal issues while at these parks—symptoms consistent with chemical exposure. California precedent establishes that counties can be liable for allowing dangerous third-party activities on public land. In Vedder v. County of Imperial, the court found a county liable for allowing explosive chemicals to be stored on property without adequate fire protection. Additionally, under California law, California Government Code § 815.6 ensures municipal tort liability when a public entity has a mandatory duty designed to protect against a specific type of injury, the entity is negligent with that duty, and the entity's negligence caused the kind of injuries that were supposed to be prevented if the entity had not been negligent in their duty. The city has mandatory duties under federal and California law with the statues at issue binding the city with requirements that are communicated with "shall," not "may." I lived at the Santa Clara Square Apartments. I made complaints to the city about chemical exposure and asked for help understanding what was happening. The city concealed what the facility was doing. I lost my job at Apple, my income, my savings, many of my friends, my reputation, my health, and my career due to my advocacy about safety and environmental hazards at this location. My toxic tort claims were dismissed due to statute of limitations, partly because the city concealed information that would have helped me discover the cause of my injuries sooner. While I lost everything, the city continued collecting tax revenue and reputational benefits from continuing to conceal and enable these dangerous operations. This case matters beyond my individual situation. I'm attempting to breathe life back into the underused EPCRA citizen suit provisions. I'm testing whether contribution and conspiracy theories can apply in environmental citizen suits when defendants cross the line from passive regulators to active participants. This case asks: What happens when the regulator becomes the enabler? Can cities hide behind immunity when they actively participate in violations rather than just failing to prevent them? The city took on enforcement responsibilities for federal environmental laws and then established policies, systems, and practices that enabled the businesses in the city to violate those same laws without consequence. The city actively concealed violations for financial benefit. The city enabled the same kind of scenario that these federal environmental laws were designed to prevent—in the very county whose disasters led to the creation of these laws. Relief against the city is necessary and will be unavailable if the city is dismissed. The venue is significant. The San Jose courthouse sits in the county where these federal environmental laws originated. The timing is significant too: semiconductor manufacturing is being re-shored to communities across America, making these questions urgent nationwide. I now live in Boston, Massachusetts. I was able to fundraise the money to purchase a plane ticket to California to attend the November 20, 2025 hearing in person. I believe the city is a necessary defendant, and their dismissal from this case would cause further irreparable harm to the community. -Ashley On June 30 2025, I served Apple, City of Santa, EPA, and the property owner notice of an incoming EPA Citizen Suit under RCRA, CAA, CWA, TSCA, and EPCRA -- as well as a public nuisance claim -- about Apple's illegal semiconductor fabrication plant at 3250 Scott Blvd in Santa Clara, California.
Read the Notice here. My request for appellate review by the US Dept of Labor's Admin Review Board was approved on August 27 2024, and the CERCLA whistleblower retaliation case is now docketed as Ashley Gjovik v Apple Inc, ARB-2024-0060, 2024-CER-00001. The U.S. Dept. of Labor ARB also issued an Order formally approving the appeal request and issuing a briefing schedule. I filed a Notice of Pendency in the civil lawsuit for our Case Mgmt Conference tomorrow. You can read the full Order in the filing here.
|
AuthorUpdates from Ashley Gjovik about her whistleblower battle against Apple Inc. Archives
November 2026
Categories
All
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
RSS Feed